Skip to main content

Rhyme and Slant Rhyme in the Poetry of Lorine Niedecker

Niedecker's various rhyme techniques, in three poems

Not all of Lorine Niedecker’s poems involve a rhyme scheme, but the ones that do vary widely in their pattern and effect.  In fact, the word “scheme” might be inappropriate.  It would be more accurate to say that she employs an “anti-rhyme scheme,” because the placement of true rhyme and slant rhyme is unpredictable.  She seems to have moved progressively toward the non-rhyming poem as she moved into the objectivism with which she
became commonly associated. These three poems serve as markers along the trajectory of her shift toward objectivism. Although all three were written early in her career, I cannot say with authority that they were written in the order they appear in The Granite Pail, or in the order I present them.  The first poem follows a scheme of true and slant end rhymes.  The second poem includes internal true rhymes, even though the rhyming words occur at the end of lines (see example for explanation), and the third poem makes the reader wait until the end of the poem to hear the true rhyme, while including a few internal rhymes.  In “The graves,” Niedecker gets as close to a symmetrical rhyming form as anything she writes:

You were my mother, thorn apple bush,
armed against life’s raw push.
but you my father catalpa tree
stood serene as now--he refused to see
that the other woman, the hummer she shaded
        hotly cared
for his purse petals falling--
        his mind in the air.

    The first two couplets are true rhymes, while the last quatrain includes two slant rhymed lines intercut by two lines that do not rhyme.  In fact, the words “shaded,” and “falling” couldn’t be any more non-rhyming.  Clearly, this was intentional.  Niedecker wanted an abrupt shift in sound, here.  The two hard “d” sounds in “shaded” serve to clip the reader from the top couplets, in order to drop us gently through white space into the short lines: “hotly cared,” and “his mind in the air.”
    At first glance, the following poem appears to have two couplets that will carry the reader through with ease.  However, one quickly runs into white space that has a disjoining effect completely different from the white space in the example above.  It seems to have the effect of erasing the rhyme that is sitting right there in plain view:

You are my friend--
you bring me peaches
and the high bush cranberry
        you carry
my fishpole
you water my worms
you patch my boot
with your mending kit
        nothing in it
but my hand

    Although these lines appear to be end rhymed couplets, when read aloud the rhymes do not fit metrically or smoothly, and can thus be considered internal rhymes.  I’ll call these two pairs of lines “phantom couplets.”  The reader has no way of knowing if they occur within a pattern, because there are not enough lines in the poem to complete the scheme.  If there were another line before the given opening line that did not end with a word rhyming with “friend,” or “peaches,” then one could reasonably extrapolate that each group of three unrhymed lines would be followed by a rhyming phantom couplet.
    The third poem begins with the line “Well, spring overflows the land,” and while there is no set rhyme scheme, there are two instances of internal slant rhymes.  The first occurs in the first stanza between the words “floods,” “floor,” and “moored.”  There are words with similar vowel sounds at the end of some of the lines.  These words, in the following order are:  land, machine, deafness, door, eye, world, washing, away, high, ears.  Finally, the last stanza provides the powerful punch of a rhyme that seems to tie the poem together:   

I’ve wasted my whole life in water.
My man’s got nothing but leaky boats.
My daughter, writer, sits and floats.
   
    Here, the last couplet is forceful because it acts as a binding agent for the rest of the poem.  While having a cohesive effect, it catches the reader off-guard due to its placement in a three-line stanza, thus “floating” on its own.  Although a boat floats on water, it does not rhyme with “water,” and the couplet serves, graphically, to underscore the fact that it is the daughter who is floating.  The second internal rhyme of the poem also occurs in this stanza, between the words “water,” “daughter,” and “writer.”
    Niedecker’s use of rhyme and slant rhyme is of the variety that can be appreciated by the reader of modern free verse for several reasons.  First, it is not “sing-song” rhyme.  Second, it avoids being kind of rhyme that tries not to appear to rhyme for the sake of setting itself apart from a bygone era of poetry.  In other words, it is a legitimate kind of rhyming, which successfully sets itself apart from that bygone era, not simply a clever tucking and hiding of rhymes and off rhymes.  Finally, Niedecker’s rhymes do something; they don’t exist in order to make everything sound better, or for the reader to more easily memorize them for later recitation around the campfire.  Although her rhyming and slant rhyming shares a few similarities with that of Emily Dickinson, there’s no way you’ll find yourself tapping them out to the tune of “The Yellow Rose of Texas,” as you can with so many poems by the Belle of Amherst.